Undervalued Insurance Stocks on NYS March 2025

March 16, 2025

Insurance

Insurance companies underwrite, market, and distribute insurance and related products to individuals, families or corporations.

New York Stock Exchange

The New York Stock Exchange, located in New York City, is the largest securities exchange in the world by market capitalization of its listed companies.

Our Valuation

A stock is considered undervalued if it trades at a discount to our valuation. To determine a stock’s intrinsic value, we developed an algorithm that uses 6 valuation models to determine the value of a company.* To learn more about stockcalc’s valuation methods, click here.

Undervalued Insurance stocks

Stocks in this category are held primarily for potential income and capital appreciation.

For an in-depth look at the fundamentals and valuation of each company, try the stockcalc platform free for 30 days.

SymbolNameClose Price ($)Valuation ($)Difference (%)Average Vol (30D)Market Cap ($M)Yield (%)P/E Ratio
MBI MBIA 5.41 15.15 179.96 450720 257 0.00 0.0
HGTY Hagerty 9.33 17.15 83.77 48877 826 0.00 93.3
PRA ProAssurance 15.71 25.35 61.37 250447 805 0.00 15.3
CIA Citizens 4.67 5.70 22.06 109913 237 0.00 10.9
SLQT SelectQuote 3.64 4.41 21.24 1944244 637 0.00 0.0
AMBC Ambac Financial Group 8.39 9.67 15.23 1178194 394 0.00 0.0
UVE Universal Insurance Hldgs 21.80 23.72 8.79 181503 638 2.94 10.8
FIHL Fidelis Insurance Hldgs 15.14 16.29 7.59 917034 1751 2.64 15.4
WDH Waterdrop 1.40 1.47 5.25 250143 521 0.00 10.1
HCI HCI Group 138.68 142.54 2.79 106718 1759 1.15 15.6
All data provided as at market close March 13, 2025.

Company Details

MBIA

MBI:NYS

Close Price

5.41

Our Valuation

15.15

% Difference

179.96

Market Cap ($M)

257

P/E Ratio

0.0

MBIA Inc provides financial guaranty insurance for municipal bonds and asset-backed securities in the United States and internationally. It offers an unconditional guarantee to repay the principal and interest on these securities if the issuer defaults. MBIA insures bonds sold in the primary and secondary markets, as well as those held in unit investment trusts and mutual funds.

Access the stockcalc valuation


Hagerty

HGTY:NYS

Close Price

9.33

Our Valuation

17.15

% Difference

83.77

Market Cap ($M)

826

P/E Ratio

93.3

Hagerty Inc is a provider of specialty automotive insurance. The company underwrites, sells, and services classic car and enthusiast vehicle insurance policies. Substantial revenue is derived from Commission and fees. Geographically it serves Europe, Canada, and the United States.

Access the stockcalc valuation


ProAssurance

PRA:NYS

Close Price

15.71

Our Valuation

25.35

% Difference

61.37

Market Cap ($M)

805

P/E Ratio

15.3

ProAssurance Corp is a holding company for property and casualty insurance companies. The company's wholly-owned insurance subsidiaries provide professional liability insurance for healthcare professionals and facilities, professional liability insurance for attorneys, and workers' compensation insurance. ProAssurance reports operating results in five segments: Specialty Property and Casualty, Workers' Compensation, Segregated Portfolio Cell Reinsurance, Lloyd's Syndicate, and Corporate.

Access the stockcalc valuation


Citizens

CIA:NYS

Close Price

4.67

Our Valuation

5.70

% Difference

22.06

Market Cap ($M)

237

P/E Ratio

10.9

Citizens Inc is an insurance holding company serving the life insurance needs of individuals in the United States. The company provides insurance benefits to residents in thirty two U.S. states and more than seventy countries through its insurance subsidiaries. the Company derives its revenues principally from life insurance premiums earned for insurance coverages provided to insureds in our two operating segments and net investment income.

Access the stockcalc valuation


Access our valuation for these companies and 9,000+ more

Try the stockcalc platform free for 30 days

Sign Up

SelectQuote

SLQT:NYS

Close Price

3.64

Our Valuation

4.41

% Difference

21.24

Market Cap ($M)

637

P/E Ratio

0.0

SelectQuote Inc is a Direct-to-consumer (DTC) distribution platform which facilitates consumers to shop for health, life and auto & home insurance policies online. The company generates its revenues by selling insurance products on behalf of the insurance carrier partners in the form of a commission. It has four reportable segments namely Senior, Healthcare Services, Life, and Auto & Home. It functions through three lines namely, SelectQuote Senior, SelectQuote Life, and SelectQuote Auto & Home.

Access the stockcalc valuation


Ambac Financial Group

AMBC:NYS

Close Price

8.39

Our Valuation

9.67

% Difference

15.23

Market Cap ($M)

394

P/E Ratio

0.0

Ambac Financial Group Inc is a financial services holding company. It operates in two principal businesses segments: Insurance Distribution and Specialty Property & Casualty Insurance. Insurance Distribution segment includes Managing General Agents, Underwriters and other appointed and delegated underwriting businesses (collectively MGAs or MGA/Us), an insurance broker, and other distribution and underwriting businesses.

Access the stockcalc valuation


Universal Insurance Hldgs

UVE:NYS

Close Price

21.80

Our Valuation

23.72

% Difference

8.79

Market Cap ($M)

638

P/E Ratio

10.8

Universal Insurance Holdings Inc is a private personal residential homeowner insurance company. The company develops, markets, and underwrites insurance products for consumers predominantly in the personal residential homeowners' lines of business and performs substantially all other insurance-related services for its primary insurance entities, including risk management, claims management, and distribution.

Access the stockcalc valuation


Fidelis Insurance Hldgs

FIHL:NYS

Close Price

15.14

Our Valuation

16.29

% Difference

7.59

Market Cap ($M)

1751

P/E Ratio

15.4

Fidelis Insurance Holdings Ltd is a specialty insurer that leverages strategic partnerships to offer tailored insurance solutions. The company classifies its business into two segments, Insurance and Reinsurance. A majority of its revenue is generated from the Insurance segment, which comprises a portfolio of property, marine, aviation and aerospace, political risk, violence and terror, energy, cyber, and other insurance risks.

Access the stockcalc valuation


Waterdrop

WDH:NYS

Close Price

1.40

Our Valuation

1.47

% Difference

5.25

Market Cap ($M)

521

P/E Ratio

10.1

Waterdrop Inc is a technology platform dedicated to insurance and healthcare service. It is a third-party insurance platform in China in terms of life and health insurance.

Access the stockcalc valuation


HCI Group

HCI:NYS

Close Price

138.68

Our Valuation

142.54

% Difference

2.79

Market Cap ($M)

1759

P/E Ratio

15.6

HCI Group Inc is engaged in the property and casualty insurance business through two Florida domiciled insurance companies, Homeowners Choice Property & Casualty Insurance Company (HCPCI) and TypTap Insurance Company (TypTap). Both HCPCI and TypTap are authorized to underwrite various homeowners' property and casualty insurance products and allied lines business in the state of Florida and other states.

Access the stockcalc valuation


Access thousands of valuation reports

Try the stockcalc platform for 30 days for unlimited access to our valuation reports

Sign Up
MBIA and Hagerty are the most undervalued Insurance stocks on the NYS. See the full list on the blog: https://www.stockcalc.com/Blog/undervalued-insurance-stocks-nys-march-2025
MBIA $MBI and Hagerty $HGTY are the most undervalued Insurance stocks on the #NYS. See the full list: https://www.stockcalc.com/Blog/undervalued-insurance-stocks-nys-march-2025
MBIA and Hagerty are the most undervalued Insurance stocks on the NYS. See the full list on the blog: https://www.stockcalc.com/Blog/undervalued-insurance-stocks-nys-march-2025

Copyright © 2016- Patchell Brook Equity Analytics Inc. All rights reserved.

Risk Disclosure: Equities trading and trading of all markets, exchanges and instruments contains substantial risk and is not for every investor. An investor could potentially lose all or more than the initial investment. Risk capital is money that can be lost without jeopardizing ones’ financial security or life style. Only risk capital should be used for trading and only those with sufficient risk capital should consider trading. Past performance is not necessarily indicative of future results. View full risk information here.